Community
Community reviews on Body By A are structured experience reports — not star ratings. The goal is to give readers something closer to a note from a friend who’s actually tried the product, not a pile of anonymous one-liners. A full writeup of our thinking lives in our reviews design notes; this page is the short version for reviewers.
Submissions go to a moderation queue. One of us (Ajay or Tessa) reads each one before it publishes — usually within 48–72 hours. This is the single most important thing we do to keep the review pages useful. It’s also why there’s a small delay between submitting and seeing your review live.
Short, first-person experience reports: what you were hoping the product would help with, how long you’ve used it, what actually changed, and whether you’d recommend it to a friend. Reviews are anchored to named reviewers (first name plus a profile chip) rather than anonymous accounts.
Reviews that attack individuals, contain unverifiable medical claims, read like marketing copy, are reviewing the wrong product, or use abusive language. We also don’t publish anonymous reviews or reviews that are clearly from a brand employee.
If a product earns a critical review that meets our guidelines, we publish it. If a pattern of critical reviews emerges, we remove the pick — we don’t remove the reviews. Brands can’t pay to take a review down, and we don’t remove reviews on brand request.
You’ll get a tokenized edit link via email when you submit. Use it to update or delete your review any time. We can fix formatting but never rewrite what you said — if something changes, you do.
Email hello@bodybya.com if a review of yours didn’t go live or you’re unsure whether something belongs in a review vs. a comment on a blog post.
Community reviews are rolling out category by category starting with Magnesium. If you want to be notified when the category you care about opens for reviews, subscribe to our newsletter.